Linear vs. Panel Grow Lights for Multi-Tier Growing. Multi-tier vertical farm rack with linear LED grow light bars over trays of lettuce.
11

Nov

Linear vs. Panel Grow Lights for Multi-Tier Growing

For a single tent with headroom, almost any well-built LED will grow plants. Racks are different. The space between shelves is short, the light has to cover a rectangle edge to edge, and every tier adds heat to the one above it. That’s why most commercial multi-tier growers use linear bars. This post explains why, and when a panel or UFO still makes sense.

The three shapes

  • Linear bars are long, narrow fixtures, often 2 to 4 ft long and a few inches wide, that run the length of a shelf. Our Edisun FXL Series linear LED grow lights are 24″ (FXL-320) and 47″ (FXL-600) long, 2.9″ wide and 3.7″ tall.
  • Panels or boards are flat, square or rectangular fixtures sized to a tent footprint, such as 2×2 or 4×4.
  • UFO lights are round, compact fixtures that hang from a single point. Our Edisun LIT Series is a UFO design.

How they compare on a rack

Linear barsPanels / boardsUFO
Fits a long, narrow shelfYes, matches the shelfPartly, often overhangs or falls shortNo, round footprint on a rectangle
Light uniformity across the tierEven along the length; add bars for widthEven within its footprintBright center, dimmer corners
Height it takes from the tierLow profile (FXL: 3.7″)Low to mediumMedium to tall
Airflow between tiersGaps between bars let heat riseSolid surface traps warm airOpen around the edge
Scaling to wider shelvesAdd another barBuy a bigger panelAdd another fixture, overlapping circles
Best place for itRacks, vertical farms, long benchesSingle tents, square footprintsSmall tents, single plants, low budgets

Why bars win on racks

They match the shape. A typical shelf is 2 ft deep and 4 ft long. A 47″ bar covers the length; two or three bars side by side cover the depth. A square panel or a round UFO has to overlap, or leave the ends dark.

They keep light even. Long bars spread their output along the row rather than concentrating it in one spot. On a shelf, where plants on the ends are often the weakest, that evenness matters more than peak brightness.

They give heat a way out. Gaps between bars let warm air rise off the canopy instead of pooling under a solid panel. Passively cooled bars like the FXL have no fans to fail or clog in a humid rack.

They scale in a straight line. Wider shelf? Add a bar. You don’t have to step up to a different fixture model.

When a panel or UFO is the better choice

  • A single tent or a square footprint. A panel sized to a 2×2 or 4×4 tent is simple and even within that square.
  • Small spaces and starter grows. A UFO such as our Edisun LIT Series hangs from one hook and lights a small tent or a few plants at low cost. It comes in two sizes: the LIT-150 covers up to a 2.75 × 2.75 ft flowering area, and the LIT-240 up to 3 × 3 ft.
  • Supplementing a greenhouse. A single UFO can fill a dark corner without rebuilding a rack.

What to check on any fixture

Whatever the shape, compare fixtures on the same numbers: PPF (total light out), µmol/J (light per watt), the PPFD map across the whole footprint rather than just the center, and the IP rating for humid rooms.

Lighting a rack? See the Edisun FXL Series linear LED grow lights. Lighting a tent? See the Edisun LIT Series UFO grow lights. Not sure? Send us your space and we’ll recommend one.

Sources

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RELATED

Posts