Greenhouse tomatoes under orange HPS light on one side and white LED bar grow lights on the other.
17

Nov

LED vs. HPS Grow Lights for Greenhouses

High-pressure sodium (HPS) lamps lit greenhouses for decades. Most new installs now go LED. Here’s how the two actually compare, including where HPS still holds its own.

Light per watt

The number that matters is photosynthetic efficacy: micromoles of plant-usable light (µmol) per joule of electricity. Higher means more light for the same power bill.

FixtureEfficacy (µmol/J)
400W HPS, magnetic ballast0.94
1000W double-ended HPS, electronic ballast1.70
LED fixtures on the DLC horticultural list2.39–3.19
Edisun FXL-320 / FXL-6002.63 / 2.65

Michigan State’s Erik Runkle sums up the current state: LED fixtures are now “at least 35% more efficient” than HPS. Against an older magnetic-ballast HPS, a modern LED bar gives well over twice the light per watt.

One honest note: not every LED beats the best HPS. Our Edisun LIT UFOs (1.42–1.46 µmol/J) are made for tents and small rooms, and a double-ended HPS outdoes them per watt. For greenhouse supplemental lighting, use a high-efficacy bar like the Edisun FXL.

What happens to the heating bill

HPS lamps throw a lot of radiant heat at the crop. In a cold greenhouse, some of that heat is useful. Switch to LED and the lighting bill drops, but the heater runs a little more.

A Wageningen University modeling study (Katzin et al., 2021) put numbers on the trade-off for a tomato greenhouse:

  • Lighting energy fell about 40%.
  • Heating energy rose 9–49%, depending on climate.
  • Total energy use still fell 10–25%.

So LEDs save money even after the extra heating, just less than the lighting numbers alone suggest. Measured canopy effects vary: a USDA-ARS comparison found HPS changed leaf temperature by anywhere from −0.6 to +1.7 °C relative to LED. For more on LED heat, see do LED grow lights need extra cooling?

Lamp replacement

HPS lamps wear out and dim as they age:

  • Standard mogul-base HPS lamps are typically replaced around 10,000 hours; double-ended lamps around 10,000–15,000 hours (Lopez, Purdue).
  • Runkle notes HPS lamps are often changed at about 12,000 hours, when they’re down to 85–90% of their original output.

At 16 hours a night through a long winter, that’s a new lamp every two years or so, plus the labor of getting up to change them. The Edisun FXL is rated for 50,000 hours.

Shading and control

  • Shading: a big HPS fixture and reflector cast a shadow on the crop all day. A slim LED bar (the FXL is 2.9″ wide) blocks far less sunlight.
  • Dimming: HPS runs at full power or off. Every Edisun light dims to 10%, so you can top up only what the sun didn’t deliver. See greenhouse supplemental lighting and when to dim your grow light.
  • Instant on: LEDs reach full output immediately. HPS lamps need several minutes to warm up and can’t restart until they cool.

When HPS still makes sense

  • You already own working HPS fixtures and the lamps are fresh.
  • Your greenhouse is in a cold climate and you count on the lamps’ heat (though Katzin’s study still found LEDs ahead overall).
  • Upfront cost matters more than operating cost this season.

The bottom line

HPSEdisun FXL LED
Light per watt0.94–1.70 µmol/J2.63–2.65 µmol/J
Lamp life~10,000–15,000 h50,000 h rated
DimmingNoDown to 10%
Shade on cropLarge fixture2.9″ bar
Heat at canopyHigh radiant heatMuch less

Replacing HPS in your greenhouse? See the Edisun FXL series, estimate your savings with our running cost calculator, or ask us for a layout.


Sources

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RELATED

Posts